Old-School Recipes, New-School Vibes.

Celestino’s is the heart of the community -

A place where good food brings people together.

Every pie we craft and every order we send out is made with care, connection, and the hope that it becomes part of your story.

We’re here for your Friday nights, your family dinners, your celebrations, and your “just because” moments. This isn’t just a pizza shop — it’s a neighborhood tradition you’ll always want to return to.

We’re not reinventing pizza. We’re doing it right.

You’ve had pizza before. But not like this. We’re taking the classics and giving them the care they deserve. Crispy, chewy, cheesy, saucy perfection—every time.

View Our Menu

We keep it hot, fresh, and worth talking about.

Order Online

Come See Us

We’re right here in the heart of town—serving up hot pies, delicious food, and good vibes daily. Whether you’re grabbing a slice, sitting for dinner, or visiting us from across the county… we can’t wait to serve you!

New Providence

590 Central Ave, New Providence, NJ 07974

(908) 450-4021

ciao@celestinos.pizza

Menu? No thanks. We studied your Instagram like it was an exam. 💯

Nothing beats a date night built around good conversation and really good food. 😋

Good food, good people, good vibes. That’s Celestino’s.

Because fresh isn’t a choice at Celestinos, it’s our standard 🍝💫

Wishing you a Thanksgiving filled with good food, good company, and moments worth savoring. From our Celestino’s family to yours, Happy Thanksgiving! 💙 🦃

Our latest location is open, bringing the flavors you love closer than ever.

Just good food and good energy.

Tender chicken, zesty sauce, and all the flavors you love on one plate.

Friday Night Vibes 🍕🍝

A little heat, a little cheese… big vibe.

We took the flavor you love from our penne alla vodka, that creamy, dreamy sauce and grilled chicken, and wrapped it up so you can take it anywhere. 🌯🔥

Now taking catering orders for Thanksgiving week! 🦃✨ Call to order and mention 10% OFF catering on orders over $100.

Some things just don't need a caption...🍫🍓😋

We keep it simple. Honest food, done right, every single time.

If cozy had a flavor… this would be it. Pillowy homemade gnocchi with roasted eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and our signature tomato sauce 🍅

Nothing to see here… just a model employee! 🤣

Nothing says comfort like a plate of our homemade meat lasagna. Fresh, flavorful, and made with heart. As Darryl said, you gotta try this!

we don't make the rules, we just make the pizza 🍕

Fresh, bright, and full of texture. The Dolce Salad keeps it simple but never boring.

One of Jay’s go-to dishes for a reason. The Chicken Luigi is rich, fresh, and made with that signature Celestino’s flavor you can taste in every bite.